With the the news of the Iranian pastor who has been sentenced to die for his Christian faith, I have to wonder where the suffering, the persecution, and the hardship is for the American church. As a part of such, sometimes I breathe a light prayer for God to send that to us, to refine us, but I admit it scares me and I am too content to really mean it. Shame on me and shame on us all. However, the desire for suffering in our churches (as crazy as that sounds) was really strengthened after reading one phrase from one sentence in Eric Metatexas’ biography of Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
When Bonhoeffer visited New York in 1930-31, he really did not find fellowship with the theologically elite from Union Seminary at Columbia University. In fact, he offered a pointed review: “The theological atmosphere of the Union Theological Seminary is accelerating the process of the secularization of Christianity in America . . . . In New York they preach about virtually everything: only one thing is not addressed, or is addressed so rarely that I have as yet been unable to hear it, namely, the gospel of Jesus Christ, the cross, sin and forgiveness, death and life.”
Do you want to know where he DID find true preaching? It was in African American churches. After visiting one with a friend in Harlem, he attended there regularly, taught Sunday school and served there, and took back with him to Germany a love for spirituals and Gospel music. What was the difference between the dry, dead theology of Union and the rich, engaging spirituality of the African American church at that time? It was pain; pain and suffering from over a century of racist subjugation. Eric Metatexas explains, “the only real piety and power that [Bonhoeffer] had seen in the American church seemed to be in the churches where there were a present reality and a past history of suffering. Somehow he had seen something more in those churches and in those Christians, something that the world of academic theology – even when it was at its best, as in Berlin – did not touch very much.”
So there is the one phrase – “a present reality and a past history of suffering.” In the past 30-40 years, in evangelical churches, do we have a present reality of suffering? No. And this begs the question as to why. Why are we not experiencing suffering & persecution? Some might say that it is simply because we live in a land where we are free. This has to be partly true. But does our status of liberty mask a deeper problem in the American church? These questions are definitely ones we should consider and begin discussing. Are we as Evangelicals more like the theological liberals that Bonhoeffer encountered in the 1930s than we’d like to admit – ones who fail to truly address sin, forgiveness, and the Gospel?